by David Johnson, Christina Erneling
The basic idea of the particular way of understanding mental phenomena that has inspired the "cognitive revolution" is that, as a result of certain relatively recent intellectual and technological innovations, informed theorists now possess a more powerfully insightful comparison or model for mind than was available to any thinkers in the past. The model in question is that of software, or the list of rules for input, output, and internal transformations by which we determine and control the workings of a computing machine's hardware. Although this comparison and its many implications have dominated work in the philosophy, psychology, and neurobiology of mind since the end of the Second World War, it now shows increasing signs of losing its once virtually unquestioned preeminence. Thus we now face the question of whether it is possible to repair and save this model by means of relatively inessential "tinkering", or whether we must reconceive it fundamentally and replace it with something different. In this book, twenty-eight leading scholars from diverse fields of "cognitive science"-linguistics, psychology, neurophysiology, and philosophy- present their latest, carefully considered judgements about what they think will be the future course of this intellectual movement, that in many respects has been a watershed in our contemporary struggles to comprehend that which is crucially significant about human beings. Jerome Bruner, Noam Chomsky, Margaret Boden, Ulric Neisser, Rom Harre, Merlin Donald, among others, have all written chapters in a non-technical style that can be enjoyed and understood by an inter-disciplinary audience of psychologists, philosophers, anthropologists, linguists, and cognitive scientists alike.
Books with similar themes and ideas
Books that connect different domains
Bridges summary
The intellectual landscape explored in *The Future of the Cognitive Revolution* by David Johnson and Christina Erneling is vividly illuminated when viewed through the lens of foundational works like Daniel Kahneman's *Thinking, Fast and Slow*. Kahneman's seminal investigation into cognitive biases, while focusing on the mechanics of *current* human thought, provides an indispensable counterpoint and a practical grounding for the ambitious future-gazing presented by Johnson and Erneling. Their book, a comprehensive collection of essays from leading scholars, grapples with the very definition and future trajectory of the cognitive revolution, a movement fundamentally shaped by the metaphor of the mind as computational software. Kahneman, in essence, offers a deeply insightful exploration of that "software" as it currently operates, revealing its often surprising quirks, inefficiencies, and ingrained biases. Understanding these inherent patterns of human cognition, as meticulously detailed by Kahneman, becomes a crucial step in appreciating the necessity and the potential directions of the "revolution" proposed by the contributors to *The Future of the Cognitive Revolution*.
Discover hidden gems with our 'Gap Finder' and explore your reading tastes with the 'Mood Galaxy'. Go beyond simple lists.
The strength of this connection lies in the shared endeavor to dissect the human mind, albeit with different temporal horizons. Kahneman’s work acts as a diagnostic, showcasing the intricate, often non-rational, processes that govern our daily judgments and decisions. This detailed autopsy of present cognitive functions directly informs the critical re-evaluation of the central metaphor of the cognitive revolution – mind as computer. If, as Johnson and Erneling suggest, this metaphor is showing signs of strain, Kahneman's dissection of how humans *actually* think, complete with System 1 and System 2 thinking, provides the empirical data that reveals the limitations or perhaps the oversimplifications inherent in purely computational models. The scholars contributing to *The Future of the Cognitive Revolution* are tasked with imagining what comes *after* the dominance of the computational metaphor. To do so effectively, one must first possess a profound understanding of the mechanisms that Kahneman so brilliantly elucidates. The user ratings and intuitive grasp of *Thinking, Fast and Slow*’s relevance suggest an audience that recognizes the vital interplay between understanding what *is* and envisioning what *could be*. This bridging cluster highlights a reader's appreciation for deep dives into cognitive architecture, making *The Future of the Cognitive Revolution* a natural progression for those who have already grappled with the intricacies of present-day thinking. The book's exploration of whether the current model can be "repaired" or requires fundamental "reconceiving" is directly informed by the very real-world cognitive phenomena Kahneman describes. The potential for "tinkering" might involve better understanding and mitigating the biases he details, while fundamental reconception could necessitate entirely new paradigms that move beyond the computer analogy altogether, perhaps incorporating insights from other domains such as embodied cognition or enactivist approaches that are implicitly or explicitly touched upon by the diverse perspectives within *The Future of the Cognitive Revolution*. This dialogue between the established understanding of present cognition and the speculative exploration of its future is where the true value of this thematic connection lies.